The Decline of New Atheism

They were called the Four Horsemen of New Atheism. It's the early 2000s and the term New Atheism is taking off. Philosophers and scientists Daniel Dennett, Richard Dawkins and Sam Harris have joined forces with journalist Christopher Hitchens to declare that not only is there no God but that everybody should understand this.


The outworking of this new belief system was most vividly shown in the 2009 bus poster campaign which boldly declared ‘There is probably no God. Now stop worrying and enjoy your life.’

But people did worry. And still worry. In the end, New Atheism was shown to be little more than a hotchpotch of old ideas, vaguely linked to science and philosophy. When the four horsemen began to fall out with each other, the decline was inevitable.

There was actually a fifth horseman – or horsewoman. Ayaan Hirsi Ali was a disciple of Richard Dawkins, proposing strong atheistic views. Originally from Somalia, she later moved to the Netherlands and then the United States, becoming increasingly well known for her opposition to extreme Islam and to Woke Identity.

In November 2023, Hirsi Ali declared her new-found faith in Christ. If New Atheism hadn't already been struggling, it now was. Hirsi Ali found the ‘long term sense of life without spiritual solace’ to be ‘unendurable’.

Ayaan Hirsi Ali inevitably concluded that there was a God. The Bible says that there is a God shaped hole in our lives (Ecclesiastes 3:11) and no amount of atheistic argument can ever fill it. That's the journey Hirsi Ali went on and it is a journey repeated by many.

An appreciation of nature and a scientific understanding of the details of biology and creation suggest that there must be more to life than a vague view that all we see is a chemical accident. In fact, many scientists reach the conclusion that there has to be a God.

Another well known ‘conversion’ is that of the British writer AN Wilson. Initially a cynic of everything Christian, he found himself drawn back to faith. His experience of atheism simply did not match his experience of real living.

Wilson said:

‘Materialist atheism says we are just a collection of chemicals. It has no answer whatsoever to the question of how we should be capable of love, of heroism, of poetry, if we're simply animated pieces of meat.’

Wilson went on to conclude ‘The more I read the Easter story, the better it seems to fit and apply to the human condition. That is why I now believe in it.’

There is a sense of Christian revival in the UK. Many from Generation Z are rejecting atheism and materialism, realising there must be more to life than this.

There is.

For a much deeper consideration of these issues, I recommend ‘The Surprising Rebirth of Beliefin God’ by Justin Brierley. Much of this article finds its roots in that book.

Previous Post Next Post